Where to Start with PDQ?

[This article was first published on The Pith of Performance, and kindly contributed to R-bloggers]. (You can report issue about the content on this page here)
Want to share your content on R-bloggers? click here if you have a blog, or here if you don't.

Once you’ve downloaded PDQ with a view to solving your performance-related questions, the next step is getting started using it. Why not have some fun with blocks? Fun-ctional blocks, that is.

Since all digital computers and network systems can be considered as a collection of functional blocks and these blocks often contain buffers, their performance can be modeled as a collection of buffers or queues. Therefore, start developing your PDQ model by drawing a functional block diagram of the relevant architecture using elements like these:


The objective is to identify how much time is spent at each stage or block as it processes the workload of interest. Ultimately, each functional block becomes converted into a queue subsystem like those shown above. This includes the ability to distinguish sequential and parallel processing. In the language of PDQ, a queue is created using a call to either CreateNode or CreateMultiNode.

Here’s how the above blocks would appear in PDQ in R as three separate models in the same R script:

<br /># PDQ fun blocks<br /># Created by NJG on Mon Aug 30 2010<br /><br />library(pdq)<br /><br />work  <- "Requests"<br />arate <- 0.75<br />Ta    <- 0.25<br />Tb    <- 0.75<br />p     <- 0.5<br /><br />Init("Sequence Fun Blocks")<br />CreateOpen(work,arate)<br />CreateNode("SeqBlock",CEN,FCFS)<br />SetDemand("SeqBlock",work,Ta+Tb)<br />Solve(CANON)<br />Report()<br /><br />Init("Parallel Fun Blocks")<br />CreateOpen(work,arate)<br />CreateNode("ParaBlock1", CEN,FCFS)<br />SetDemand("ParaBlock1",work,p*Ta)<br />CreateNode("ParaBlock2",CEN,FCFS)<br />SetDemand("ParaBlock2",work,(1-p)*Tb)<br />Solve(CANON)<br />Report()<br /><br />Init("Repetition Fun Blocks")<br />CreateOpen(work,arate)<br />CreateNode("RepBlock",CEN,FCFS)<br />SetDemand("RepBlock",work,Ta/(1-p))<br />Solve(CANON)<br />Report()<br />
Notice that each PDQ model is essentially just a list of queues. That’s really all a PDQ model is: work name, queue name, service time, repeat. When all the queues (blocks) are listed, just Solve it.

We can easily check the output of the “Sequence Fun Blocks” model. Since the combined service demand equals 1.0 second and the arrival rate is 0.75 per second, the residence time (R) had better be R = 1/(1 – (3/4)) = 4 seconds. And indeed, the RESOURCE Performance section of the PDQ Report reveals that to be correct.

<br />                ******   RESOURCE Performance   *******<br /><br />Metric          Resource     Work              Value   Unit<br />------          --------     ----              -----   ----<br />Throughput      SeqBlock     Requests         0.7500   Trans/Sec<br />Utilization     SeqBlock     Requests        75.0000   Percent<br />Queue length    SeqBlock     Requests         3.0000   Trans<br />Waiting line    SeqBlock     Requests         2.2500   Trans<br />Waiting time    SeqBlock     Requests         3.0000   Sec<br />Residence time  SeqBlock     Requests         4.0000   Sec<br />
The online PDQ manual contains more information about PDQ functions. Models of this type are developed as an iterative process. Do not expect to get everything correct and validated in a single pass. That never happens and if it does, you probably made a mistake in understanding either the PDQ model or the measurements used to parameterize the PDQ model. On the other hand, the good news is that you can start with almost any preliminary sketch of the functional blocks and converge to a more accurate PDQ model over time.

Other diagrammatic techniques e.g., UML diagrams, may also be useful but I don’t understand that stuff so I’ve never tried it. If anyone does try that approach I’d be interested to hear about it.

See Chap. 6 “Pretty Damn Quick(PDQ)—A Slow Introduction” in my Perl::PDQ book for more ideas.

To leave a comment for the author, please follow the link and comment on their blog: The Pith of Performance.

R-bloggers.com offers daily e-mail updates about R news and tutorials about learning R and many other topics. Click here if you're looking to post or find an R/data-science job.
Want to share your content on R-bloggers? click here if you have a blog, or here if you don't.

Never miss an update!
Subscribe to R-bloggers to receive
e-mails with the latest R posts.
(You will not see this message again.)

Click here to close (This popup will not appear again)