Add Pvalues and Significance Levels to ggplots
Want to share your content on Rbloggers? click here if you have a blog, or here if you don't.
In this article, we’ll describe how to easily i) compare means of two or multiple groups; ii) and to automatically add pvalues and significance levels to a ggplot (such as box plots, dot plots, bar plots and line plots …).
Contents:
Prerequisites
Install and load required R packages
Required R package: ggpubr (version >= 0.1.3), for ggplot2based publication ready plots.
 Install from CRAN as follow:
install.packages("ggpubr")
 Or, install the latest developmental version from GitHub as follow:
if(!require(devtools)) install.packages("devtools") devtools::install_github("kassambara/ggpubr")
 Load ggpubr:
library(ggpubr)
Official documentation of ggpubr is available at: http://www.sthda.com/english/rpkgs/ggpubr
Demo data sets
Data: ToothGrowth data sets.
data("ToothGrowth") head(ToothGrowth) len supp dose 1 4.2 VC 0.5 2 11.5 VC 0.5 3 7.3 VC 0.5 4 5.8 VC 0.5 5 6.4 VC 0.5 6 10.0 VC 0.5
Methods for comparing means
The standard methods to compare the means of two or more groups in R, have been largely described at: comparing means in R.
The most common methods for comparing means include:
Methods  R function  Description 

Ttest  t.test()  Compare two groups (parametric) 
Wilcoxon test  wilcox.test()  Compare two groups (nonparametric) 
ANOVA  aov() or anova()  Compare multiple groups (parametric) 
KruskalWallis  kruskal.test()  Compare multiple groups (nonparametric) 
A practical guide to compute and interpret the results of each of these methods are provided at the following links:
 Comparing onesample mean to a standard known mean:
 Comparing the means of two independent groups:
 Comparing the means of paired samples:

Comparing the means of more than two groups
 Analysis of variance (ANOVA, parametric):
 KruskalWallis Test in R (non parametric alternative to oneway ANOVA)
R functions to add pvalues
Here we present two new R functions in the ggpubr package:
 compare_means(): easy to use solution to performs one and multiple mean comparisons.
 stat_compare_means(): easy to use solution to automatically add pvalues and significance levels to a ggplot.
compare_means()
As we’ll show in the next sections, it has multiple useful options compared to the standard R functions.
The simplified format is as follow:
compare_means(formula, data, method = "wilcox.test", paired = FALSE, group.by = NULL, ref.group = NULL, ...)
 formula: a formula of the form x ~ group, where x is a numeric variable and group is a factor with one or multiple levels. For example, formula = TP53 ~ cancer_group. It’s also possible to perform the test for multiple response variables at the same time. For example, formula = c(TP53, PTEN) ~ cancer_group.

data: a data.frame containing the variables in the formula.

method: the type of test. Default is “wilcox.test”. Allowed values include:
 “t.test” (parametric) and “wilcox.test”” (nonparametric). Perform comparison between two groups of samples. If the grouping variable contains more than two levels, then a pairwise comparison is performed.
 “anova” (parametric) and “kruskal.test” (nonparametric). Perform oneway ANOVA test comparing multiple groups.

paired: a logical indicating whether you want a paired test. Used only in t.test and in wilcox.test.

group.by: variables used to group the data set before applying the test. When specified the mean comparisons will be performed in each subset of the data formed by the different levels of the group.by variables.

ref.group: a character string specifying the reference group. If specified, for a given grouping variable, each of the group levels will be compared to the reference group (i.e. control group). ref.group can be also “.all.”. In this case, each of the grouping variable levels is compared to all (i.e. basemean).
stat_compare_means()
This function extends ggplot2 for adding mean comparison pvalues to a ggplot, such as box blots, dot plots, bar plots and line plots.
The simplified format is as follow:
stat_compare_means(mapping = NULL, comparisons = NULL hide.ns = FALSE, label = NULL, label.x = NULL, label.y = NULL, ...)

mapping: Set of aesthetic mappings created by aes().

comparisons: A list of length2 vectors. The entries in the vector are either the names of 2 values on the xaxis or the 2 integers that correspond to the index of the groups of interest, to be compared.

hide.ns: logical value. If TRUE, hide ns symbol when displaying significance levels.

label: character string specifying label type. Allowed values include “p.signif” (shows the significance levels), “p.format” (shows the formatted p value).

label.x,label.y: numeric values. coordinates (in data units) to be used for absolute positioning of the label. If too short they will be recycled.

…: other arguments passed to the function compare_means() such as method, paired, ref.group.
Compare two independent groups
Perform the test:
compare_means(len ~ supp, data = ToothGrowth) # A tibble: 1 x 8 .y. group1 group2 p p.adj p.format p.signif method1 len OJ VC 0.06449067 0.06449067 0.064 ns Wilcoxon
By default method = “wilcox.test” (nonparametric test). You can also specify method = “t.test” for a parametric ttest.
Returned value is a data frame with the following columns:
 .y.: the y variable used in the test.
 p: the pvalue
 p.adj: the adjusted pvalue. Default value for p.adjust.method = “holm”
 p.format: the formatted pvalue
 p.signif: the significance level.
 method: the statistical test used to compare groups.
Create a box plot with pvalues:
p < ggboxplot(ToothGrowth, x = "supp", y = "len", color = "supp", palette = "jco", add = "jitter") # Add pvalue p + stat_compare_means() # Change method p + stat_compare_means(method = "t.test")
Note that, the pvalue label position can be adjusted using the arguments: label.x, label.y, hjust and vjust.
The default pvalue label displayed is obtained by concatenating the method and the p columns of the returned data frame by the function compare_means(). You can specify other combinations using the aes() function.
For example,
 aes(label = ..p.format..) or aes(label = paste0(“p =”, ..p.format..)): display only the formatted pvalue (without the method name)
 aes(label = ..p.signif..): display only the significance level.
 aes(label = paste0(..method.., “\n”, “p =”, ..p.format..)): Use line break (“\n”) between the method name and the pvalue.
As an illustration, type this:
p + stat_compare_means( aes(label = ..p.signif..), label.x = 1.5, label.y = 40)
If you prefer, it’s also possible to specify the argument label as a character vector:
p + stat_compare_means( label = "p.signif", label.x = 1.5, label.y = 40)
Compare two paired samples
Perform the test:
compare_means(len ~ supp, data = ToothGrowth, paired = TRUE) # A tibble: 1 x 8 .y. group1 group2 p p.adj p.format p.signif method1 len OJ VC 0.004312554 0.004312554 0.0043 ** Wilcoxon
Visualize paired data using the ggpaired() function:
ggpaired(ToothGrowth, x = "supp", y = "len", color = "supp", line.color = "gray", line.size = 0.4, palette = "jco")+ stat_compare_means(paired = TRUE)
Compare more than two groups
 Global test:
# Global test compare_means(len ~ dose, data = ToothGrowth, method = "anova") # A tibble: 1 x 6 .y. p p.adj p.format p.signif method1 len 9.532727e16 9.532727e16 9.5e16 **** Anova
Plot with global pvalue:
# Default method = "kruskal.test" for multiple groups ggboxplot(ToothGrowth, x = "dose", y = "len", color = "dose", palette = "jco")+ stat_compare_means() # Change method to anova ggboxplot(ToothGrowth, x = "dose", y = "len", color = "dose", palette = "jco")+ stat_compare_means(method = "anova")
 Pairwise comparisons. If the grouping variable contains more than two levels, then pairwise tests will be performed automatically. The default method is “wilcox.test”. You can change this to “t.test”.
# Perorm pairwise comparisons compare_means(len ~ dose, data = ToothGrowth) # A tibble: 3 x 8 .y. group1 group2 p p.adj p.format p.signif method1 len 0.5 1 7.020855e06 1.404171e05 7.0e06 **** Wilcoxon 2 len 0.5 2 8.406447e08 2.521934e07 8.4e08 **** Wilcoxon 3 len 1 2 1.772382e04 1.772382e04 0.00018 *** Wilcoxon # Visualize: Specify the comparisons you want my_comparisons < list( c("0.5", "1"), c("1", "2"), c("0.5", "2") ) ggboxplot(ToothGrowth, x = "dose", y = "len", color = "dose", palette = "jco")+ stat_compare_means(comparisons = my_comparisons)+ # Add pairwise comparisons pvalue stat_compare_means(label.y = 50) # Add global pvalue
If you want to specify the precise y location of bars, use the argument label.y:
ggboxplot(ToothGrowth, x = "dose", y = "len", color = "dose", palette = "jco")+ stat_compare_means(comparisons = my_comparisons, label.y = c(29, 35, 40))+ stat_compare_means(label.y = 45)
(Adding bars, connecting compared groups, has been facilitated by the ggsignif R package )
 Multiple pairwise tests against a reference group:
# Pairwise comparison against reference compare_means(len ~ dose, data = ToothGrowth, ref.group = "0.5", method = "t.test") # A tibble: 2 x 8 .y. group1 group2 p p.adj p.format p.signif method1 len 0.5 1 6.697250e09 6.697250e09 6.7e09 **** Ttest 2 len 0.5 2 1.469534e16 2.939068e16 < 2e16 **** Ttest # Visualize ggboxplot(ToothGrowth, x = "dose", y = "len", color = "dose", palette = "jco")+ stat_compare_means(method = "anova", label.y = 40)+ # Add global pvalue stat_compare_means(label = "p.signif", method = "t.test", ref.group = "0.5") # Pairwise comparison against reference
 Multiple pairwise tests against all (basemean):
# Comparison of each group against basemean compare_means(len ~ dose, data = ToothGrowth, ref.group = ".all.", method = "t.test") # A tibble: 3 x 8 .y. group1 group2 p p.adj p.format p.signif method1 len .all. 0.5 1.244626e06 3.733877e06 1.2e06 **** Ttest 2 len .all. 1 5.667266e01 5.667266e01 0.57 ns Ttest 3 len .all. 2 1.371704e05 2.743408e05 1.4e05 **** Ttest # Visualize ggboxplot(ToothGrowth, x = "dose", y = "len", color = "dose", palette = "jco")+ stat_compare_means(method = "anova", label.y = 40)+ # Add global pvalue stat_compare_means(label = "p.signif", method = "t.test", ref.group = ".all.") # Pairwise comparison against all
A typical situation, where pairwise comparisons against “all” can be useful, is illustrated here using the myeloma data set from the survminer package.
We’ll plot the expression profile of the DEPDC1 gene according to the patients’ molecular groups. We want to know if there is any difference between groups. If yes, where the difference is?
To answer to this question, you can perform a pairwise comparison between all the 7 groups. This will lead to a lot of comparisons between all possible combinations. If you have many groups, as here, it might be difficult to interpret.
Another easy solution is to compare each of the seven groups against “all” (i.e. basemean). When the test is significant, then you can conclude that DEPDC1 is significantly overexpressed or downexpressed in a group xxx compared to all.
# Load myeloma data from survminer package if(!require(survminer)) install.packages("survminer") data("myeloma", package = "survminer") # Perform the test compare_means(DEPDC1 ~ molecular_group, data = myeloma, ref.group = ".all.", method = "t.test") # A tibble: 7 x 8 .y. group1 group2 p p.adj p.format p.signif method1 DEPDC1 .all. Cyclin D1 1.496896e01 4.490687e01 0.14969 ns Ttest 2 DEPDC1 .all. Cyclin D2 5.231428e01 1.000000e+00 0.52314 ns Ttest 3 DEPDC1 .all. Hyperdiploid 2.815333e04 1.689200e03 0.00028 *** Ttest 4 DEPDC1 .all. Low bone disease 5.083985e03 2.541992e02 0.00508 ** Ttest 5 DEPDC1 .all. MAF 8.610664e02 3.444265e01 0.08611 ns Ttest 6 DEPDC1 .all. MMSET 5.762908e01 1.000000e+00 0.57629 ns Ttest 7 DEPDC1 .all. Proliferation 1.241416e09 8.689910e09 1.2e09 **** Ttest # Visualize the expression profile ggboxplot(myeloma, x = "molecular_group", y = "DEPDC1", color = "molecular_group", add = "jitter", legend = "none") + rotate_x_text(angle = 45)+ geom_hline(yintercept = mean(myeloma$DEPDC1), linetype = 2)+ # Add horizontal line at base mean stat_compare_means(method = "anova", label.y = 1600)+ # Add global annova pvalue stat_compare_means(label = "p.signif", method = "t.test", ref.group = ".all.") # Pairwise comparison against all
From the plot above, we can conclude that DEPDC1 is significantly overexpressed in proliferation group and, it’s significantly downexpressed in Hyperdiploid and Low bone disease compared to all.
Note that, if you want to hide the ns symbol, specify the argument hide.ns = TRUE.
# Visualize the expression profile ggboxplot(myeloma, x = "molecular_group", y = "DEPDC1", color = "molecular_group", add = "jitter", legend = "none") + rotate_x_text(angle = 45)+ geom_hline(yintercept = mean(myeloma$DEPDC1), linetype = 2)+ # Add horizontal line at base mean stat_compare_means(method = "anova", label.y = 1600)+ # Add global annova pvalue stat_compare_means(label = "p.signif", method = "t.test", ref.group = ".all.", hide.ns = TRUE) # Pairwise comparison against all
Multiple grouping variables
 Two independent sample comparisons after grouping the data by another variable:
Perform the test:
compare_means(len ~ supp, data = ToothGrowth, group.by = "dose") # A tibble: 3 x 9 dose .y. group1 group2 p p.adj p.format p.signif method1 0.5 len OJ VC 0.023186427 0.04637285 0.023 * Wilcoxon 2 1.0 len OJ VC 0.004030367 0.01209110 0.004 ** Wilcoxon 3 2.0 len OJ VC 1.000000000 1.00000000 1.000 ns Wilcoxon
In the example above, for each level of the variable “dose”, we compare the means of the variable “len” in the different groups formed by the grouping variable “supp”.
Visualize (1/2). Create a multipanel box plots facetted by group (here, “dose”):
# Box plot facetted by "dose" p < ggboxplot(ToothGrowth, x = "supp", y = "len", color = "supp", palette = "jco", add = "jitter", facet.by = "dose", short.panel.labs = FALSE) # Use only p.format as label. Remove method name. p + stat_compare_means(label = "p.format")
# Or use significance symbol as label p + stat_compare_means(label = "p.signif", label.x = 1.5)
To hide the ‘ns’ symbol, use the argument hide.ns = TRUE.
Visualize (2/2). Create one single panel with all box plots. Plot y = “len” by x = “dose” and color by “supp”:
p < ggboxplot(ToothGrowth, x = "dose", y = "len", color = "supp", palette = "jco", add = "jitter") p + stat_compare_means(aes(group = supp))
# Show only pvalue p + stat_compare_means(aes(group = supp), label = "p.format")
# Use significance symbol as label p + stat_compare_means(aes(group = supp), label = "p.signif")
 Paired sample comparisons after grouping the data by another variable:
Perform the test:
compare_means(len ~ supp, data = ToothGrowth, group.by = "dose", paired = TRUE) # A tibble: 3 x 9 dose .y. group1 group2 p p.adj p.format p.signif method1 0.5 len OJ VC 0.03296938 0.06593876 0.033 * Wilcoxon 2 1.0 len OJ VC 0.01905889 0.05717667 0.019 * Wilcoxon 3 2.0 len OJ VC 1.00000000 1.00000000 1.000 ns Wilcoxon
Visualize. Create a multipanel box plots facetted by group (here, “dose”):
# Box plot facetted by "dose" p < ggpaired(ToothGrowth, x = "supp", y = "len", color = "supp", palette = "jco", line.color = "gray", line.size = 0.4, facet.by = "dose", short.panel.labs = FALSE) # Use only p.format as label. Remove method name. p + stat_compare_means(label = "p.format", paired = TRUE)
Other plot types
 Bar and line plots (one grouping variable):
# Bar plot of mean +/se ggbarplot(ToothGrowth, x = "dose", y = "len", add = "mean_se")+ stat_compare_means() + # Global pvalue stat_compare_means(ref.group = "0.5", label = "p.signif", label.y = c(22, 29)) # compare to ref.group # Line plot of mean +/se ggline(ToothGrowth, x = "dose", y = "len", add = "mean_se")+ stat_compare_means() + # Global pvalue stat_compare_means(ref.group = "0.5", label = "p.signif", label.y = c(22, 29))
 Bar and line plots (two grouping variables):
ggbarplot(ToothGrowth, x = "dose", y = "len", add = "mean_se", color = "supp", palette = "jco", position = position_dodge(0.8))+ stat_compare_means(aes(group = supp), label = "p.signif", label.y = 29) ggline(ToothGrowth, x = "dose", y = "len", add = "mean_se", color = "supp", palette = "jco")+ stat_compare_means(aes(group = supp), label = "p.signif", label.y = c(16, 25, 29))
Infos
This analysis has been performed using R software (ver. 3.3.2) and ggpubr (ver. 0.1.3).
Rbloggers.com offers daily email updates about R news and tutorials about learning R and many other topics. Click here if you're looking to post or find an R/datascience job.
Want to share your content on Rbloggers? click here if you have a blog, or here if you don't.