Posts Tagged ‘ refereeing ’

PLoS computational biology meets wikipedia

May 26, 2012
By
PLoS computational biology meets wikipedia

Robin Ryder pointed out to me this new experiment run by PLoS since March 2012, namely the introduction of a new article type, “called “Topic Pages” and written in the style of a Wikipedia article“. Not only this terrific idea gives more credence to Wikipedia biology pages, at least in their early stage, but also

Read more »

Number of components in a mixture

August 5, 2011
By
Number of components in a mixture

I got a paper (unavailable online) to referee about testing for the order (i.e. the number of components) of a normal mixture. Although this is an easily spelled problem, namely estimate k in I came to the conclusion that it is a kind of ill-posed problem. Without a clear definition of what a component is,

Read more »

How to avoid annoying a referee

October 22, 2010
By

It’s not a good idea to annoy the referees of your paper. They make recommendations to the editor about your work and it is best to keep them happy. There is an interesting discussion on stats.stackexchange.com on this subject. This inspired my own list below. Explain what you’ve done clearly, avoiding unnecessary jargon. Don’t claim

Read more »